Ukraine frequently draws parallels between its own struggle against aggression and Israel's trauma, invoking shared experiences to rally international support. Despite these emotional appeals, Ukraine has consistently voted against Israel's security interests at the United Nations, most recently supporting the extension of the mandate for an agency criticized for ties to extremist groups. This pattern reveals a contradiction between Ukraine's calls for solidarity and its actions on the world stage, as it supports resolutions that many see as undermining Israel's right to self-defense. The article argues that true solidarity requires consistency, urging Ukraine to apply the same moral standards to Israel that it seeks for itself in its time of crisis.