West Midlands Police chief Craig Guildford has retired amid controversy over the handling of a football match between Aston Villa and Maccabi Tel Aviv, where police were found to have fabricated and exaggerated evidence to justify banning Israeli fans. Despite being praised by the police and crime commissioner for his 'honour' in stepping down, Guildford faced mounting pressure from the Home Secretary and members of Parliament to resign. He is now considering legal action for constructive dismissal, seeking a significant payout, while the Independent Office for Police Conduct is reviewing potential misconduct. The situation has sparked political debate, with some condemning his retirement terms and others criticizing the process that led to his departure.