Immigration Minister Tony Burke is facing criticism over alleged 'double standards' after Australia revoked the visa of Israeli politician Simcha Rothman due to his inflammatory comments, while allowing controversial Muslim speakers with histories of supporting terrorist organisations to enter the country. The decision has sparked a diplomatic dispute, with Israel revoking visas for Australian representatives and threatening further scrutiny of Australian visa applications. Critics, including opposition politicians and Jewish community leaders, argue that the government's visa decisions appear inconsistent and lack transparency, particularly in light of previous approvals for speakers who have publicly celebrated the Hamas attacks of October 7.

Documents from the Department of Home Affairs suggest Rothman's visa was cancelled over concerns his presence could incite division and hate crimes within Australia's Muslim community. Meanwhile, speakers such as Sami Hamdi and Mohammed Ghuloom, who have praised terrorist leaders and organisations, were permitted to tour Australia, prompting further accusations of bias in the government's approach. The controversy has intensified calls for Immigration Minister Burke to clarify the criteria and processes guiding these decisions.

Foreign Minister Penny Wong has condemned Israel's retaliatory actions as unjustified, emphasizing the need for dialogue and diplomacy amid rising tensions. The government maintains its commitment to protecting community safety and preventing the spread of hate, but faces mounting pressure to explain its visa policies and address claims of inconsistency.