The controversy surrounding Israel's conscription bill, often referred to as the Bismuth bill, has been marked by heated rhetoric and polarized accusations. Public discourse has focused more on labeling opponents as 'ultra-Orthodox haters' or as aiding political adversaries, rather than engaging with the actual content and implications of the legislation. This environment has stifled meaningful debate and obscured the real issues at stake. The article highlights four fundamental mistakes made by those supporting the bill, suggesting that the conversation has been derailed by slogans rather than substance.