President Isaac Herzog has strongly criticized the government's decision to establish a politically controlled probe into the October 7, 2023, Hamas-led assault, warning that such an approach could undermine the search for truth and erode public trust. Speaking at a Bible study event in Jerusalem, Herzog reiterated his call for a state commission of inquiry, emphasizing the need for a thorough and independent investigation into the failures that led to the massacre. The government's move to create a political committee has sparked protests from opposition lawmakers and bereaved families, who argue that only a state commission appointed by judicial authorities can ensure impartiality.

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and his allies have rejected calls for an independent probe, insisting that a political investigation is the only form the public will trust, despite polls showing broad support for a state commission. The proposed political committee would be appointed by a Knesset supermajority, but opposition figures have pledged to boycott the process, citing concerns over coalition control. Herzog acknowledged the deep pain of bereaved families and former hostages, stressing that they deserve clear answers and warning that politicizing the inquiry could significantly harm efforts to learn from the tragedy.