Academic boycotts in response to the war in Gaza are reshaping the landscape of global science, isolating Israeli researchers and fragmenting international collaboration. While intended as a protest against government policy, these boycotts often harm those with the least political power and the greatest potential to foster positive change. The author, a college president and researcher, argues that refusing to engage with Israeli scientists undermines the shared pursuit of knowledge and delays research crucial for rebuilding lives. Instead of closing doors, the scientific community should uphold high standards, challenge one another, and continue collaborating across divides to address global challenges that transcend borders.