The author writes a heartfelt letter to Poland's Chief Rabbi Michael Schudrich, expressing deep admiration for his role in reviving Jewish life in Poland after the Holocaust. However, the author candidly disagrees with Rabbi Schudrich's recent public criticism of Israel regarding its conduct in the war against Hamas, arguing that such statements risk misrepresenting Israel's humanitarian efforts and inadvertently lend support to harmful narratives.

The letter highlights Israel's unprecedented record of delivering humanitarian aid to Gaza during the conflict, contrasting it with historical wartime actions by other nations. The author contends that Hamas, not Israel, is responsible for the suffering of civilians by obstructing aid and using civilians as human shields. He warns that public criticism from prominent rabbis can be weaponized by those seeking to delegitimize Israel, especially amid rising antisemitism.

Emphasizing the importance of moral clarity, the author urges Rabbi Schudrich and other Jewish leaders to ensure their words reflect the truth about the conflict and Israel's efforts. The letter concludes with a plea for solidarity and responsible leadership, stressing the need to support Israel and counter falsehoods during a time of global hostility.