Thanksgiving's origins are deeply intertwined with Jewish history, as early Puritans saw themselves as a new Israel, drawing inspiration from the Hebrew Bible and the Exodus story. This connection shaped America's moral foundation, with figures like Benjamin Franklin proposing national symbols rooted in the biblical narrative. Today, the meaning of chosenness is often misunderstood or misrepresented, but it originally signified moral responsibility and gratitude, not superiority or exclusion. The article warns against modern distortions of this legacy by both the far right and left, emphasizing that true freedom is grounded in faith, humility, and thankfulness. Visiting the Touro Synagogue, the author reflects on George Washington's message of safety and goodwill for all, underscoring that gratitude, not power, is the key to enduring liberty and unity in America.