At the recent Turning Point USA AmericaFest conference, Vice President JD Vance delivered a speech that has sparked concern among conservatives and Jewish Americans. Rather than addressing the boundaries of acceptable discourse within the conservative movement, Vance emphasized a 'big tent' approach that avoids excluding even those who espouse antisemitic or extremist views. This stance was highlighted in the context of debates at the conference, where figures like Ben Shapiro argued for setting limits to keep hate-mongers out, while others such as Tucker Carlson and Megyn Kelly opposed any form of gatekeeping.

Vance's refusal to denounce antisemites or conspiracy theorists signals a shift in the conservative coalition, suggesting that the movement is willing to tolerate, if not embrace, voices that promote bigotry. Critics argue that this approach undermines the moral foundation of conservatism and alienates those who oppose antisemitism. The article warns that by failing to draw clear lines against hate, the Republican Party risks losing the support of Jews and other voters who value America's alliance with Israel and oppose extremism.

While Vance's rhetoric about America as a 'Christian nation' was not the main focus, his omission of any condemnation of Jew-hatred was seen as a deliberate choice. The piece concludes that this new direction could leave those committed to fighting antisemitism and supporting Israel without a political home in the coming years.