image sourced from original article at Argentina's chief Sephardic rabbi, Yosef Chehebar, has reaffirmed a century-old ban on Jewish conversions performed within Argentina, stating that only those carried out in Israel are valid. This move has sparked strong criticism from non-Orthodox Jewish groups, who argue that the restriction is outdated and undermines the legitimacy of local conversion processes, which they say are rigorous and well-established.
The ban, originally enacted in 1927 to address concerns over irregular conversions among immigrants, is described as permanent and binding, intended to safeguard the integrity of Jewish lineage. Critics contend that the reasons for the ban no longer apply, and accuse Orthodox authorities of seeking to monopolize religious authority and exclude non-Orthodox practices.
Rabbi Isaac Sacca defended the ruling as a measure to ensure the seriousness and authenticity of conversions, emphasizing that it is not meant to reject sincere converts but to maintain high standards. Non-Orthodox leaders, however, insist their conversions are legitimate and will continue to welcome new members into the Jewish community with dignity.
