Several major Jewish organizations in New York chose not to sponsor Mayor Zohran Mamdani's first annual interfaith breakfast, reflecting deep concerns within the city's Jewish community about his past anti-Israel positions. The editorial argues that for many Jews in New York, support for Israel is integral to their religious and cultural identity, and Mamdani's rhetoric and policies have contributed to a climate of anxiety, especially as antisemitic incidents rise. The absence of these organizations from the event is portrayed not as a rejection of interfaith dialogue, but as a cautious response to what they see as City Hall's failure to address their real fears and experiences. The piece concludes that restoring trust will require more than dialogue; it will require concrete action from the mayor to address antisemitism and reassure the Jewish community.